Jean Guild Grant 2023: Charlie Ellis
Project aims and background
The Table Tennis in Edinburgh research project by Dr Charlie Ellis is examining, recording and analysing the early decades of competitive table tennis in Edinburgh. It builds on previous research related to the 100th anniversary of Murrayfield Table Tennis Club. This addresses an overlooked chapter in the history of the city with relevance well beyond sport.
Charting the early years of competitive table tennis in Edinburgh and the development of the local league, this involves organising and synthesising the documentation and other material (photographs, interview transcripts) already collated, and adding to this. There has been no previous attempt to do so. There is a significant gap in Edinburgh’s history as many thousands have played the sport in dozens of clubs across the city. Furthermore, the city produced a world champion in the sport – Helen (Hamilton) Elliot of the Gambit Club. Gambit began as an offshoot of Stockbridge Chess Club formed in 1938. From these modest beginnings it went on to provide all five of Scotland’s team for the 1955 World Championships in Stockholm.
Despite this, table tennis has left virtually no imprint on the recorded history of the city. It also forms a significant gap in Scottish sporting history, as it was a sport with large participation in the middle of the 20th century. It is generally absent from works on Scottish sport (eg, Jarvie & Burnett, Sport, Scotland and the Scots, Tuckwell Press Ltd, 2000). It is to be expected that the sport lacks the rich literature devoted to football, rugby, golf and cricket but it suffers even in comparison to other ‘minor’ sports such as badminton, hockey and curling. This project attempts to redress this.
The story of table tennis in Edinburgh also shines some light on some interesting aspects of Edinburgh’s social history, including political controversy (one club being populated by members of the Young Communist League) and the leading role played by Polish soldiers stationed in Edinburgh in the post-war table tennis boom. It also includes some interesting details regarding the buildings in which table tennis tournaments and exhibition matches were played. Places such as Epworth Hall (Nicolson Square) and Oddfellows’ Hall (Forrest Road).
Fortunately, a rich set of documentation and photographs does exist. This project will involve organising the large amount of material collated over the decades by, in particular, Michael MacLaren, Lindsay Muir and Bert Kerr. This rich archive of documents, photographs and manuscripts, needs to be properly organised catalogued, with the most important parts of it digitised. Having the archive in a more coherent shape will assist with creating a more coherent picture of the development of chronology of the sport, as well as providing the basis for publications.
Dr Charlie Ellis
Charlie Ellis was awarded a PhD in politics at Sheffield University and then conducted post-doctoral research at the Institute for Advanced Studies in the Humanities (IASH), University of Edinburgh. He has worked subsequently at a number of private language schools in Edinburgh. He has written scholarly articles on politics and public intellectuals, and is currently working on a book and articles on British conservatism and culture. He has written fairly extensively on table tennis, including many pieces for the Table Tennis Scotland (TTS) website. He wrote a series relating to the 100th anniversary of Murrayfield Table Tennis Club in 2022, along with a 8,500 word history of the Club.
Project activities
Charlie’s main focus is on organising and digitising the large amount of material that he has collated in the last few years. Most of the material is unique and were it to be lost or damaged, it could not be replaced. This collection includes an unpublished handwritten manuscript which details the early years (1938-1960) of Gambit Table Tennis Club by R. F. D. Hayman. There are also large batches of papers cuttings, a collection of handbooks and bulletins, league material, minute books and photos all to be digitised for posterity. To make the archive and the history comprehensive, it needs to be be supplemented by material from other sources, such as Edinburgh City Archives, the National Library of Scotland and contemporary newspapers.
Intended outputs and results
A number of research outputs are planned, targeted a range of audiences. These should help Table Tennis Scotland raise the profile of table tennis and attract more historical material about the sport. This research will also reveal a largely ignored chapter in the social as well as sporting history of Edinburgh. For example, many clubs were formed in companies and these clubs (and their closure in the 1980s) tells us much about the shifting patterns of employment in the city.
News of project progress
Updated news items from Dr Ellis are available to view. He has also gave a great presentation to OEC members at the AGM in September 2024.
Miss Jean Ritchie Guild
This project has been supported by a Jean Guild Grant, named after our benefactor, a long-standing member of the OEC. She joined the staff of the University of Edinburgh Library in 1948, later becoming Reference Librarian, much-respected for her skills and knowledge, especially in relation to the Faculty of Arts. Later she was responsible for publicity, Library publications, visitor programmes, and the Library’s relationship with the wider community.